Skip to content

how all this ends

how i figure out the end of a novel

Published by C. L. Clark in writing craft Share

I’ve gotten this question a couple times in the last month from people winding down the first drafts of their novels. People worry if they’re conclusive enough, too conclusive, or if they’re even hitting the right notes.

At first, it filled me with a wild panic: what do you mean you’ve gotten to the end and you don’t know how it ends?!

That’s just the kind of writer I am, though. I typically know the ending from the beginning, and that comes down to four things (and none of them require being a strict outliner):

Because of a combination of the above, my endings often suggest themselves, usually in the brainstorming or outlining process. Not necessarily the exact final scene, but the general status quo of the characters and/or the world. Like any good plan, however, contact with the enemy (aka the page) may change things.

(nb: general but not specific spoilers for the Magic of the Lost trilogy ending below; if you haven’t finished The Sovereign, grab it, read it, then come back)


When I started writing The Unbroken, assuming it was going to be a two book series, I knew one thing: Luca wouldn’t keep her crown.

I was exploring revolutions and colonialism in fantasy, and the idea of a just ruler who would make it all okay—the prevailing narrative of monarchy for the fantasy of generations before. (And while I generally think writing the answer to a thematic question you want to explore before you’ve even started may keep you from learning anything new in the writing process, you can still write with the questions, “Is this what would happen? Could this happen?”)

This shifted only slightly when I realized I was going to write three books instead of two. It was pretty easy to determine that the halfway stop between the revolution in Book 1 (The Unbroken) and the fall in Book 3 (The Sovereign) was success—Luca would ascend her throne in Book 2 (The Faithless).

From the outside, that’s a pretty standard trajectory, triangle shaped. Freytag pyramid-esque.

When I started The Unbroken, I didn’t know the climax of The Sovereign was going to be a massive four-nation battle with all of these different holy magics coming to bear (ha). I didn’t know who would even be alive by the end of the series! Most of these decisions were a result of the progression of the narrative, which, to me, means a progression of the characters and their decisions as they interact with the ever-changing world.

The Sovereign, as the “ending” book and the ending of that book, therefore, were the result of all of those decisions for the hundreds of pages that came before The Sovereign’s first chapter. That book spilled from me like an inevitability. I knew all the major beats because they were the only things that felt possible given the histories of the characters—and their nations—and all the choices made along the way.

It was the first book where I wasn’t wondering, “What scene goes here? What happens next?” I just knew because the weight of all that came before left certain consequences that had to be enacted. You don’t get to stop a boulder rolling downhill, and diverting it should cost greatly. Once I set the last of the pieces in motion at the end of book two, these forces had to collide at some point, somehow—otherwise, that would have been a massive broken promise. Anti-climactic, one might say.

So, a big part of determining your ending is understanding reader expectations.

We all will have different relationships with our audience. They may be your besties in the group chat, they may be your editor, your mom, your 50,000 followers who all like the same shadow daddy. We can’t always control how they’re going to come to a piece, and you may want to disregard them entirely! (For my part, my first audience is myself. I’ve always been the person its most important to me to please, in all areas of my life; luckily, I have decent standards.)

But if we’re working in a certain literary tradition, trying to sell in a certain market, know what you’re doing before you try to disrupt expectations completely. It can be WILDLY effective, but it has to be done well, and that is a harder thing to express in an essay.

Assuming we’re going to meet the expectations of a Western media market, one thing I’ve always resonated with is the MICE quotient, started by Orson Scott Card (👎) and adapted by Mary Robinette Kowal, who made it very easy to understand with a graphic (because I’m not sure she’s ever shared it publicly outside of her paid Patreon, I’m not going to share it here) that also discusses nesting them like coding brackets.

Each letter in MICE stands for a different driving force of narrative. Milieu (location-oriented), Inquiry (question-oriented), Character (internal change-oriented), Event (external change-oriented). If you start with a character leaving or arriving at a place, a reader will likely expect the ending to involve another location-based happening—leaving the place they arrived at (or vice versa), or deciding to stay/never return. Each of these aspects has a natural arc. The character (or the relationship) changes for better or for worse, the status quo of the world returns to normal or is broken beyond repair, the mystery is solved.

And then, the idea with the brackets is that a novel will have multiples of these threads, and so you close them in the order you opened them for maximum satisfaction. Therefore, if you know what kind of story you’re telling, you’ll know what needs to happen for a satisfying ending. This can be as subtle or obvious as you want, and obviously, you may not no specifics immediately. There are also ways to subvert this expectation, but you must make that call and have to look elsewhere for how you’ll satisfy your audience. If you can do it, you can do it. You don’t need my permission.

For another example, The Sovereign starts with a chapter that is part funeral, part asking what future Luca and Touraine can possibly have together, and how fragile that is. At the end, we get that answer! A funeral, a future, and a lot of broken things. But! At the start of The Unbroken, we start with a boat. An arrival. It’s a Milieu story. And the last scene of The Sovereign? Another boat. The promise of a departure. So was the big story a character story about Touraine? Yes? An event story about kingdoms and revolutions? Also yes. But none of those are what we start with. (Astute observers will also note the Milieu ending is closed last in The Unbroken with the decision to stay in Qazal and not leave.)

There are bonus things that happen in series, of course, like brackets that open at the middle or end of a book so that you have a plot to go through the next books, which keeps things from having dull lulls where nothing of import or high stakes is happening. If everything wraps up, you’re just writing connected standalones. Which may be what you want! But it wasn’t what I wanted. I wanted a “standalone with series potential.”


Warmongers is a bit trickier to analyse in the MICE way because of its structure, but I also knew its ending before I ever started writing (years before 😮‍💨). I needed to know it to sell it on proposal (when you sell an unwritten book on the basis of a few chapters and a synopsis). I hit on the ending during the outline process and, like The Sovereign, it felt inevitable given the themes I was working with and the shape of the two lead character arcs.

Despite that, I never felt stifled in my exploration of the book, which actually did change significantly from the original outline and the synopsis I sent with the proposal. The core of the outline—the magic system, the two main characters and their history together, and the ending—stayed throughout the first draft and into the end of the second.

The final chapter, I’m not sure exactly when I came up with it, but it was before I even put pen to the first draft. It’s actually not at all a MICE closure, compared to the second to last chapter. Does that make it an epilogue? I suppose we’ll have to find out. Despite what it is (no, I’m not spoiling it), I think it offers some pretty definitive answers, while still giving us the satisfactory feeling of callbacks just like closing the MICE nesting brackets does.


For me, that’s the ultimate test.

Does the end satisfy the beginning?

Does it resolve the internal and external narrative arcs?

Does it answer whatever question is in the heart of the story at the beginning?

If you know the arcs of your story well, you’ll easily be able to come up with reasonable conclusions. There’ll probably be many, and the hard part will be picking one!

But you also don’t have to write toward a known ending. That inevitability will build as you build the story up around it. You take enough forks in the road and eventually you have to arrive at a destination.

Just avoid stopping at any old place because you’re tired of walking.

Blessings from the Patron Saint of Sword Lesbians.

  • Early access to the next works-in-progress.
    Read sneak peeks, deleted scenes, and bonus stories. Get the behind-the-scenes process shots from napkin scribbles to epic series.
  • Read with me.
    Get reading recommendations and follow along with the worlds and histories that inspire me and my work.
  • Hone the body. Hone the mind. Soften the Heart.
    Commentary on the life I’m trying to live, from workouts and swordplay to understanding humanity and storytelling in “unprecedented times.”

Subscribe for updates, deleted scenes, bonus stories, and more from C. L. Clark.

Personal information