Butches in Books
Updating the list of my favorite butches in (mostly) fantasy
“Butch. Stud. Dyke. Masc. Androgynous. Masculine women have been called and called themselves many things over time. We have always existed, even when we’ve been persecuted for the ways we look, the roles we refuse to fit into, and the roles we claim instead.”
A few years ago—probably for the release of The Faithless—I was asked by Google Books to come up with a themed list of books for them to feature. I wasn’t sure where to go with it, at first, but eventually I settled on what I knew best and what I knew I could come up with an appreciable number of. It was also what I wish someone might have curated for me once.
(I’m also aware that not all of us masc of center peeps hold the identity of ‘woman’ but I was dealing with a very certain marketing audience and a tiny word count that didn’t allow for the precise caveat that I’m making now. )
I also know that people are often looking for this—I used to see the posts on twitter all the time: “Where are the butches? Where are the masculine women?”
It’s true that, societally, while many associate the word “lesbian” with masculine women, associate us with ugliness, coarseness, even the patriarchy itself. It comes from inside and outside of the queer communities we find ourselves in. At the same time, in media, it can feel like we’re under-represented. Those same biases made it so that, for a long time, it was only acceptable to show femme women who were interested in media, women who at the very least might look like they were interested in men sometimes.
Luckily, I think that’s changing, not necessarily in visual media, but certainly in mainstream textual media. (This isn’t even to start on assumptions of femme/femme or butch/femme pairings to the exclusion of two masculine partners, but that’s a topic for a different day. As you may know, I’m more fond of a different binary: the knight/commander or sword/conniver.) (It also doesn’t account for indie publishing, where there have continuously been butches, especially in queer indie presses.) Still, it can be difficult sometimes to find what you’re looking for when, in a fantasy world, gender isn’t signified in the same way it is in our world. So we look for certain attitudes, certain professions, and ways of physicality. Certain understandings of one’s body in relation to others, especially other women and queer people.
Below, you’ll find a few more butches I’ve met in books since the original list came out, or books that I didn’t have room to include. I’ve also included the SFF titles from the original list so that it doesn’t vanish one day. Most of the characters below are lesbians or find themselves in lesbian relationships at some point in the narratives they’re in, but sexuality isn’t always something to be bound and labeled; not to mention, some may have certain duties to their houses. On the whole, I tried to include only those who rang true to me. I realize that might not be the same for all of us. Oh well!
I hope you enjoy. And obviously, if you have more—share them in the comments!
Stay sharp,
C. L.
*The links below are affiliate links and I do get a kickback if you purchase a book through them, either at my UK Bookshop.org or my US Bookshop.org.
All of my books. Obviously.
Call me Traitor, Everina Maxwell

(pre-order this now and thank me later, ugh!!)
Pasha the Storm, Linda H. Codega

The Blacktongue Thief and The Daughters’ War, Christopher Buelhman


(Galva, my love!)
The Kindom Trilogy, Bethany Jacobs

Daughter of Mystery, Heather Rose Jones

The Shipwright and the Shroudweaver, Rafael Torrubia

The Duke, Anna Cowan

(not strictly fantasy, but it’s in a world where things are -different-
Fire Logic, Laurie J. Marks

The Wings upon Her Back, Samantha Mills

Valerin the Fair, Rien Gray
Savage Rebellion Trilogy, Matt Wallace

Song of the Huntress, Lucy Holland

The Isle in the Silver Sea, Tasha Suri

The Everlasting, Alix Harrow

Godkiller, Hannah Kaner

Spear, Nicola Griffith

Metal from Heaven, august clarke

Scapegracers, H. A. Clarke

The Drowning Empire Trilogy, Andrea Stewart

The Queens of Innis Lear and Lady Hotspur, Tessa Gratton


The Winged Histories, Sofia Samatar

The Traitor Baru Cormorant, Seth Dickinson

Gideon the Ninth, Tamsyn Muir

A Master of Djinn, P. Djeli Clark

Alanna series, Tamora Pierce

The Thousand Names, Django Wexler

Legends and Lattes, Travis Baldree

The Midnight Lie duology, Marie Rutkoski

Nottingham, Thorn, Compass Rose, Anna Burke



The Tiger’s Daughter, K. Arsenault Rivera

Thanks for reading. If you like these ad-free, AI-less posts, please consider supporting my work by becoming a paid subscriber, dropping a tip in the tip jar, or buying a book for a friend.